
I now know the true meaning of anarchy.
Forget Bakunin -- all you need to know can be found at a birthday party populated by one-year-old children. Several days ago we took Baby Ink to a gathering called to celebrate the first birthday of one of his friends. I hate parties more than just about anything else in the world -- unless, that is, Elaine Benes is dancing -- so I was not looking forward to the event. Above all, I was dreading having to talk to the other fathers, with whom I have nothing in common but successful sperm. Please don't misunderstand me: I don't think that I'm better than les autres papas; I simply know in advance that they will want to talk sport, drills and hammers, miles per gallon, horsepower, beards, beer, and the safest way to grab a crocodile. None of them ever wants to talk ink.
I decided, then, to hide behind Baby Ink and watch how he interacted with other children of a similar age. (Come to think of it, as I'm supposed to be interested in culture at a professional level, the gifts taken to the party are probably tax-deductible. Note to self: go through the bins to find the receipts.)
It was a feral affair. At the age of twelve months, children have no sense whatever of social convention, of how to behave towards others. Culture is, as Louis Althusser once put it, still lying in wait for them; its rules have yet to sink in and do their work. One of the ways in which this anarchic condition manifests itself, I noticed at the party, is in the blissful absence of the concept of sharing. If another child was playing with a toy that caught the eye of my untamed son, he would simply grab it for himself, enjoy it for a few moments, and then watch as it was snatched away by another toddling animal. At one point, perhaps fearing that a no-holds-barred wrestling bout was on the verge of erupting, one of the mothers (the dads were in the kitchen, huddled around the radio for the latest cricket score) shouted out, 'Share! Share nicely!'
I suppose that I will need before long to sit Baby Ink down, get out a copy of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, and talk about why it's good to share. But how will I explain that it's not always appropriate, that sharing is good only sometimes. I find the rules of polite society puzzling at the best of times (I think that this is why I adore Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm, as each relentlessly exposes the inexplicably arbitrary nature of social conventions), so I'm probably not the best person to be entrusted to explain the nuances of sharing to an anarchic infant.
I'll need to tell him, for instance, that sharing fountain pens is not the done thing. Personally, I don't really mind if someone trustworthy uses one of my precious objects to jot down a line or two -- I always think of the act in terms of a possible conversion for the church of ink -- but many people seem to view sharing their nibs as unthinkable. (Was Lévi-Strauss wrong? Is the prohibition against 'inkcest', not incest, the universal rule?)
Ink fact, the Inkette's younger sister, the Medinkette (so named because she is training to be a doctor), reported this week that she had noticed precisely this prohibition against sharing nibs during a meeting with one of her tutors. When the moment came for her to make a note of something, the Medinkette made it known that she didn't have a writing instrument with her. Empty-handed, she glanced longingly at the fountain pen held by her teacher, as if to say, 'Could I just borrow that for a second?' The tutor, sensing the bold attempt to cross a forbidden line, asked her if she was aware of the fact that he was holding a fountain pen. Sharing, he implied, was simply not an option.
Sharing, in other words, is sheared in two. (It's no accident that sharing and shearing share a linguistic root.) Any decent human being, the story goes, would share his or her last bottle of water if stranded with another person in the desert. Or, to invoke another scene from Seinfeld, it's polite to spare a square. But when a fountain pen is involved, a violent prohibition against sharing raises its head.
How will I ever explain this strange inkonsistency to Baby Ink? How will I incite him to share, to learn that only wild animals like lions keep everything for themselves ... but also, when ink is inkvolved, inkcite him to keep the lion's share for himself?
Ink not shared with anyone else today: Noodler's Aircorp Blue-Black.








